I think I may have finally found the World of Darkness replacement I've been searching for.
I downloaded Cryptworld, a clone of 1st edition Chill, because it was on sale.
I picked up Creature Feature (the book that lets you play the monsters) at a Half-Price Books in Overland Park when I attended KantCon last summer.
I downloaded Majus today after waffling on it for awhile.
So... Cryptworld provides the framework, Majus the rules for, you know, mages, and Creature Feature lets you play vampires, werewolves, mummies, and ghosts.
I think I may have finally replaced WoD. Granted, it kind of invalidates all the work I did on my Fudge Darkness game, but... mission accomplished?
We shall see...
Incidentally, I have 2nd edition Mayfair Chill and some supplements for it, but I don't know how compatible Mayfair and Pacesetter are off the top of my dome.